About Me

Thursday, July 22, 2010

City of Bones: 2.5 Stars




When fifteen-year-old Clary Fray heads out to the Pandemonium Club in New York City, she hardly expects to witness a murder — much less a murder committed by three teenagers covered with strange tattoos and brandishing bizarre weapons. Clary knows she should call the police, but it's hard to explain a murder when the body disappears into thin air and the murderers are invisible to everyone but Clary.




Equally startled by her ability to see them, the murderers explain themselves as Shadowhunters: a secret tribe of warriors dedicated to ridding the earth of demons. Within twenty-four hours, Clary's mother disappears and Clary herself is almost killed by a grotesque demon. But why would demons be interested in ordinary mundanes like Clary and her mother? And how did Clary suddenly get the Sight? The Shadowhunters would like to know....



So my Mortal Instruments-obsessed friend made me read City of Bones, I'm sorry if you're a fan or anything but I really disliked this novel.

Plot: The plot was at okay, not good but not horrible either. A lot of the time I couldn't help but compare City of Bones with Harry Potter.

The Circle: Reverse Order of the Phoenix/Deatheaters
Valentine: Voldermort/Malfoy/Darth Vader
The Clave: The Ministry of Magic.
Silent Brothers/Dementors

Basically the plot wasn't too original. And it dragged on and on, there were a lot of scenes that were not necessary, like one of the characters turning into a rat. And I still don't know what a Stele exactly does,seriously, I can't remember how it looks like or the Runes, there's no explanation about them either. How are they magical? Can different Runes do different things? Plotholes everywhere. The romance was rushed...and characters loved each other within two weeks of knowing each other.

Characters: And this is what annoyed me the most. The characters I'm supposed to like are bratty and shallow and the ones I actually like, they're treated like crap.

Clary: I hated her the most. She had to be the most annoying out of the lot, she's selfish, bitchy, sarcastic and  seems to be having an attitude problem. She's described as geeky, liking mangas and comics but we never see an extension of it. She turns on people too quickly just because they give her a little of attitude. She said all those horrible things(I won't spoil them, but things that are very close to the heart). I was glad when Alec hit her but in the end he apologized to her. All of them apologize to Clary but she nevers has to apologize to anyone. She was very pety, she wanted to smack Jace for looking cool in the heat or she wanted to throw hot soup on Isabelle just because Simon was oogling at Isabelle because she's hot. There were some reeamble qualities about her but not too many. A Mary Sue and I have a slight suspicion she might be a self-isenrt of Cassandra Clare. Clare, Clary?

Jace: Am I supposed to be swoon and charmed by him? He was an okay character but he didn't have the desired effect on me. He was supposed to be witty and funny but a lot of his lines seemed to be forced on him, making them came off as unnatural. He comes off as too arrogant and I feel bad for his horrible past but his angst was getting tiring. I also have no absolute idea as to why he might "love" Clary after all.

Simon: I liked him sometimes but very much dislike him the next moment. He's way too overprotective of Clary and he gets treated like crap by her yet he loves after "10" years. Again, no idea why. I felt so bad for him: "Half of your attention is better than somebody's whole attention." My God, dude, look for someone who cares about you. He was idotic enough to drink some strange potion ugh...I though he cared for Isabelle or at least her beauty but alas no, he was just using her to make Clary jealous.

Isabelle: I actually liked her character. She was supposed to be the bitchy girl but I have a thing for the underdog. I don't understand why she was jealous of Clary, Isabelle is described twice as beautiful. I wished she would've done more to defend herself when she was antagonize by Clary. Isabelle even helped Clary to get ready, hours later Clary called Isabelle a bitch because of something that wasn't her fault. Ugh.

Alec: I loved him the best. Felt his unrequired love for someone(it wasn't for Clary, thank God, but that's all I'm saying) he gets accused of being a coward by Clary for never killing a demon, of course he hasn't killed them, he's too busy protecting Isabelle and Jace.  I was so mad when he apologized to Clary when he didn't have to.

Magnus: We don't get too see him too much but he was a rather funny and intriguing character :D
His witty lines do come off as natural.

Setting:
It was allright, typical NYC. I wish they would gone more about Idris, or The Bone City but nope.

Writing Style: Another thing that I disliked. It was full of purple prose and strange similes. The dialogue was witty and clever but it was overused, all the characters had something witty to say. And Jace eyes are described over a 100 times.

Overall:
Cliched plot, Mary Sues, "hot boys" and over-used dialogue make up City of Bones, boy, am I glad that I didn't waste any money on them and borrowed it from my friend. Sadly, I wasted time. Maybe I'm overpicky but all this book is getting from me is a: 2.5 out of 5.

Adieu.

No comments:

Post a Comment